In Stock Butt Plugs

    Filter

      Butt plugs for every experience level, made of 100% body-safe materials. These anal plugs are top picks for safe anal warmup and even long-term wear. Flared bases ensure a secure fit.

      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Little Demon Firmer Black Silicone Dildo / Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Little Demon Firmer Black Silicone Dildo / Anal Plug
      SquarePegToys®
      69.00
      Quick view
      Avant Free Spirit - Silicone Butt Plug & Vibrator - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Avant Free Spirit - Silicone Butt Plug & Vibrator - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Avant Free Spirit - Silicone Butt Plug & Vibrator
      Blush Novelties
      27.99
      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Twister Super Soft Silicone Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Twister Super Soft Silicone Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Twister Super Soft Silicone Dildo
      SquarePegToys®
      99.00
      Quick view
      Anal Adventure Photon Butt Plug
      Anal Adventures Photon Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Anal Adventures Photon Plug
      Blush Novelties
      19.99
      Sale
      Quick view
      3-Piece Rosebud Glass Butt Plug Training Kit - Hamilton Park Electronics
      3-Piece Rosebud Glass Butt Plug Training Kit - Hamilton Park Electronics
      3-Piece Rosebud Glass Butt Plug Training Kit
      Gläs
      59.99 29.99 Save 30.00
      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Triple Wave SuperSoft Silicone Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Triple Wave SuperSoft Silicone Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Triple Wave SuperSoft Silicone Dildo
      SquarePegToys®
      99.00
      Quick view
      Challenge Anal Plug Liquid Silicone by 665 - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Challenge Anal Plug Liquid Silicone by 665 - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Challenge Anal Plug Liquid Silicone by 665
      665
      from 18.99
      Quick view
      Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Beaded Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Beaded Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Blush Anal Adventures Platinum Beaded Plug
      Blush Novelties
      14.99
      Sale
      Quick view
      Pleasure Droplets Anal Training Kit - 3 Glass Plugs - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Pleasure Droplets Anal Training Kit - 3 Glass Plugs - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Pleasure Droplets Anal Training Kit - 3 Glass Plugs
      Gläs
      59.99 29.99 Save 30.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Boundless Vibrating Beaded Plug - 10 Functions - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Boundless Vibrating Beaded Plug - 10 Functions - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Boundless Vibrating Beaded Plug - 10 Functions
      CalExotics
      30.99 25.99 Save 5.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Amethyst Rain Butt Plug being held
      Amethyst Rain Butt Plug in hand
      3.25" Amethyst Rain Butt Plug by Gläs
      Gläs
      24.99 17.99 Save 7.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Vibrating Ass Blaster - Inflatable Butt Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Vibrating Ass Blaster - Inflatable Butt Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Vibrating Ass Blaster - Inflatable Butt Plug
      Pipedream
      103.99 36.99 Save 67.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Oblong Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Oblong Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Oblong Anal Plug
      Shots
      19.99 14.99 Save 5.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      4" Beaded Glass Butt Plug with Tapered Base by Gläs
      4
      4" Beaded Glass Butt Plug with Tapered Base by Gläs
      Gläs
      30.99 20.99 Save 10.00
      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Ballistic Tiny SuperSoft Bronze Silicone Large Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Ballistic Tiny SuperSoft Bronze Silicone Large Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Ballistic Tiny SuperSoft Bronze Silicone Large Plug
      SquarePegToys®
      79.00
      Quick view
      Oxballs Gruntlock Asslock & Cock Ring - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Oxballs Gruntlock Asslock & Cock Ring - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Oxballs Gruntlock Asslock & Cock Ring
      Oxballs
      99.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Anal Adventures Cosmos 3-Plug Booty Set - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Anal Adventures Cosmos 3-Plug Booty Set - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Anal Adventures Cosmos 3-Plug Booty Set
      Blush Novelties
      87.99 69.99 Save 18.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Kong Large Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Kong Large Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Kong Large Vibrating Butt Plug with Remote
      Evolved
      109.99 49.99 Save 60.00
      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Double Scoop - SuperSoft Beaded Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Double Scoop - SuperSoft Beaded Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Double Scoop - SuperSoft Beaded Anal Plug
      SquarePegToys®
      89.00
      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Triple Header SuperSoft Silicone Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Triple Header SuperSoft Silicone Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Triple Header SuperSoft Silicone Dildo
      SquarePegToys®
      129.00
      Quick view
      Ditto Plus from We-Vibe - Vibrating Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Ditto Plus from We-Vibe - Vibrating Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Ditto Plus from We-Vibe - Vibrating Rechargeable Silicone Anal Plug
      We-Vibe
      129.00
      Sale
      Quick view
      Advanced Vibrating Snug Plug with Free Lube Bundle - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Snug Plug Vibrating with Free Lube Bundle - Hamilton Park Electronics
      b-Vibe Advanced Vibrating Snug Plug with Free Lube Bundle
      B-Vibe & Intimate Earth
      118.85 from 99.99 Save 18.86
      Quick view
      SquarePegToys® Cob-a-Squat Corn Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Cob-a-Squat Corn Dildo - Hamilton Park Electronics
      SquarePegToys® Cob-a-Squat Corn Dildo
      SquarePegToys®
      99.00
      Quick view
      Double Dipper Liquid Silicone by 665 - HUGE Beaded Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Double Dipper Liquid Silicone by 665 - HUGE Beaded Plug - Hamilton Park Electronics
      Double Dipper Liquid Silicone by 665 - HUGE Beaded Plug
      665
      from 39.95