The Best Beginner Anal Plug Kits & Finding Your Perfect Fit

When you are a beginner to anal play, it can be overwhelming trying to figure out where to start, especially when there are so many sizes, functions, and materials out there for anal toys! Fortunately, we have compiled a list of kits that are perfect for those who are just getting started in anal play, seasoned players, and even those who want a little something extra!

Why Anal Plug Kits Are Worth It

A quality anal plug kit usually includes two to four plugs that gradually increase in size. This lets you get comfortable with one size before moving on to the next, without having to make multiple purchases to get your favorite set!

Rather than rushing into something your body isn't ready for, you can take your time and let your muscles naturally adapt. Not only do the kits include more than one plug, but they also let you play around with different preferences day to day! Perhaps you want something small to accompany penetration, or maybe you want to be left feeling full - the adventure is up to you.

Even experienced users often continue using smaller plugs, so don't think of the first size as something you'll "outgrow." Different sizes can serve different purposes depending on comfort and experience. These are muscles that you can train to expand or tighten.

What Makes a Good Beginner Plug?

Not every anal plug marketed toward beginners is actually beginner-friendly. Whether it’s functions, materials, or shape - there is a lot to keep an eye out for! Here are some of our most important highlights when looking for a good beginner anal plug:

Body-Safe Materials

Silicone is one of the most popular choices because it's soft, flexible, non-porous, and easy to clean.

Other quality materials include stainless steel and glass, though many first-time users prefer silicone because it has a little more give and feels less intimidating. That extra flexibility in silicone also allows you to wear it for longer, if you prefer!

A Tapered Tip

A gently tapered tip makes insertion much smoother than toys with a blunt end, especially when paired with water-based lubrication. Remember - there is no such thing as too much lube in anal play!

This gradual shape allows your body to relax naturally instead of feeling like it's being forced open.

A Narrow Neck

A good plug has a narrower section after the bulb. Once inserted, this allows your muscles to rest comfortably around the neck while helping keep the plug securely in place.

A Flared Base

This is one feature you should never compromise on! No flared base = lost in space.

A flared base helps prevent the toy from moving too far into the body and makes removal simple and safe. Only use toys specifically designed for anal play…Seriously.

Finding Your Perfect Size

Bigger does not always mean better in the case of sex toys. In all actuality, it’s about comfort, and if you've never explored anal play before, starting with the smallest plug in a beginner kit is almost always the best approach. We even recommend lubricating your finger first before ever picking up the smallest plug, especially if it’s your first time.

Once the smallest size feels comfortable to insert, wear, and remove, you may decide to move up to the next size during a future session. Some people progress within days, while others stay with one size for months, and both are completely normal. This is all about your own unique pleasure experience.

NEVER Skip the Lubricant

Even the best beginner plug won't feel comfortable without adequate lubrication. Since the anus doesn't produce natural lubrication, applying a generous amount of lubricant to both yourself and the toy is essential for comfort, and you should never feel shy about reapplying whenever needed.

It often transforms an experience from uncomfortable to smooth and enjoyable.

Take Your Time

The goal isn't simply inserting a plug. Set aside enough time that you don't feel rushed, take slow breaths, and if something feels uncomfortable - stop! Anal play is not supposed to hurt, and when you take time to build gradually, it can take your self-care to the next level.

Our Favorite Beginner Anal Plug Kits

If you're looking for an easy place to start, here are our favorite beginner anal kits to get you started, and beyond!


The Perfect First-Timer Kit:

Meet the 3-Plug Anal Trainer Kit. This set is perfect for those who are just getting started, with 3 silicone, tapered plugs to choose from. Add a little lubrication and get ready to play! These are perfect for both solo and partnered play.

They measure at: Small: 3-inch insertable length; 3.25 inch total length; 0.75 inch width. Medium: 3.75 inch insertable length; 4 inch total length; 1 inch width. Large: 4.75 inch insertable length; 5 inch total length; 1.25 inch width

A Step Up:

Meet the Silicone Anal Exerciser Kit. This kit has three progressing plugs, much like the other, but with a wider T-base and extra thickness along the neck. This allows for a more filling experience, a little extra weight, and safer longer-term wear with the thicker flared base.

They measure at: Probe #1: 1.08 inches maximum diameter; 2.9 inches insertable length; 3.5 inches total length. Probe #2: 1.25 inches maximum diameter; 3.5 inches insertable length; 4.15 inches total length. Probe #3: 1.5 inches maximum diameter; 4.2 inches insertable length; 4.8 inches total length

Want Some Vibration?:

Meet the Climb Anal Trainer Kit. This set of 2 plugs includes a vibrating larger plug to add even more sensation while you explore and play! The more rounded design of the plugs gives you a fuller internal experience while still keeping them beginner-friendly.

They measure at: Small: 3.15 inch total length; 2.75 inch insertable length; 1.1 inch max. insertable diameter. Medium: 3.65 inch total length; 3 inch insertable length; 1.35 inch max. insertable diameter. Large: 4.75 inch total length; 3.9 inch insertable length; 1.55 inch max. insertable diameter.